turbotax vs hr block

TurboTax vs. H and R Block vs. Local Accountant: What’s Best for Your Taxes?

/in /by

Tax season can be stressful, especially when you’re unsure which filing option is best for your situation.

If you are confused about which option to choose, it’s time to learn more about each option and see which one suits you best.

Between online tax software like TurboTax (10 million people used it this year to file their taxes for free, Fortune informs), hybrid services like H&R Block, and hiring a local accountant, each option offers distinct advantages depending on your financial needs, comfort level, and budget.

Understanding tax software comparison, and particularly the difference between TurboTax vs. H&R Block, can help you make an informed decision and potentially save both time and money.

TurboTax: The Leader in DIY Tax Software

TurboTax is one of the most popular online tax filing platforms, known for its ease of use, automation, and accessibility.

TurboTax features are ideal for individuals who feel comfortable filing their own taxes but still want some guided support.

Pros of TurboTax:

  • User-Friendly Interface: TurboTax simplifies the process with step-by-step prompts that feel like a conversation.
  • Automation: The software automatically imports W-2s, 1099s, and even investment data from many employers and institutions.
  • On-Demand Help: TurboTax Live allows users to connect with certified tax experts or CPAs for an additional fee.
  • Audit Support: They offer guidance if the IRS audits your return.

Cons of TurboTax:

  • Cost: While basic returns can be free, more complex filings, especially involving investments, self-employment, or rental income, can become expensive.
  • Upselling: TurboTax frequently promotes premium add-ons, which can frustrate users looking for a straightforward experience.

Best For: Individuals with simple to moderately complex tax situations who are tech-savvy and want control over their return.

H&R Block: Hybrid Convenience and In-Person Options

H&R Block bridges the gap between DIY and professional help.

You can file your taxes online, like with TurboTax, or visit one of their physical offices for in-person support.

H&R Block benefits:

  • Multiple Filing Options: You can start your return online, then seamlessly switch to in-person assistance if you get stuck.
  • Affordable Professional Support: H&R Block tax pros can handle complex cases at a lower cost than many private accountants.
  • Physical Locations: Thousands of offices nationwide mean personal help is always nearby.
  • Transparent Pricing: Compared to TurboTax, H&R Block’s pricing structure tends to be more straightforward.

Cons of H&R Block:

  • Less Intuitive Software: While improving, H&R Block’s interface is slightly less streamlined than TurboTax’s.
  • Varying Quality: The experience may differ depending on the expertise of the tax preparer at your local branch.

Best For: Filers who prefer having both digital convenience and the reassurance of local, in-person assistance when needed.

Local Accountant: Personalized Expertise and Peace of Mind

Hiring a local accountant or Certified Public Accountant (CPA) offers the highest level of customization and professional oversight.

This option is especially valuable if you:

  • Own a business
  • Have multiple income sources
  • Need specialized tax advice.=

Pros of a local accountant:

  • Personalized Service: Accountants tailor their work to your financial situation, providing strategic advice for tax savings and long-term planning.
  • Expertise: CPAs are trained to handle complex filings, audits, and multi-state returns.
  • Time Savings: They handle all the paperwork, calculations, and deadlines so you can focus on other priorities.
  • Audit Representation: Most accountants will represent you directly if the IRS audits your return.

Cons of a Local Accountant:

  • Cost: Personalized service comes at a higher price, depending on the complexity of your return.
  • Scheduling: You may need to book appointments well in advance during tax season.

Best For: Business owners, freelancers and remote workers, investors, or anyone with a complicated financial picture seeking professional accuracy and long-term financial planning.

TurboTax vs. H&R Block vs. Local Accountant: Choosing the Right Fit

The decision largely depends on what you value most: control, cost, or confidence.

  • Choose TurboTax if you’re comfortable navigating technology and your finances are straightforward.
  • Choose H&R Block if you like having online convenience but still want the option of in-person help.
  • Choose a local accountant if you have complex taxes, want ongoing financial guidance, or prefer human expertise.

For many, hybrid solutions may work best, using online software for basic filing but consulting a local accountant for advice or year-end planning.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is TurboTax Cheaper Than Hiring an Accountant?

Yes, TurboTax is generally much cheaper than hiring a local accountant.

However, the cost can increase if you need premium versions or live CPA assistance.

Accountants, while more expensive, may uncover deductions that offset their fees.

Which Option Gives the Biggest Refund?

The size of your refund depends on your specific financial details, not the platform.

That said, local accountants often identify more deductions and credits, particularly for business owners and investors.

Can I Use TurboTax or H&R Block for a Business?

Yes, both offer business filing options.

TurboTax Self-Employed and H&R Block Premium cater to freelancers and small business owners, though a CPA may still provide a deeper tax strategy.

Is H&R Block More Reliable Than TurboTax?

Both are reputable, but H&R Block offers the advantage of in-person support if you prefer to meet with someone face-to-face.

TurboTax excels in user experience and automation.

When Should I Hire a Local Accountant?

You should hire a local accountant if you have multiple income streams, own rental properties, run a business, or simply want expert guidance on long-term financial planning and tax efficiency.

Can I Switch Between Options Each Year?

Absolutely.

You can use TurboTax for one year, try H&R Block the next, or move to a CPA if your taxes become more complex.

The key is choosing the service that fits your current needs and financial goals.

The Best Tax Filing Option Depends Entirely on Your Situation

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the TurboTax vs. H&R Block vs local accountant debate.

The best choice depends on your personal comfort level, budget, and tax complexity.

If you are looking for tax and accounting services in Las Cruces, then Master Accounting and Tax Services is the best choice for you.

We are Arizona’s premier accounting, taxes, and bookkeeping company with 20+ experience in the business.

Contact us to learn more about our services today.

Expert Controller Services in Gilbert AZ
Turn to Master Accounting and Tax Service for professional controller services tailored to your business goals. With over 20 years of experience, our expert team ensures precise financial management, compliance, and reporting—giving you the clarity and control needed to grow your business with confidence.
Call (480) 456-4999 or contact us today to get started!